National Health Forum requests Centre to ban e-cigarettes

New Delhi: National Health Forum, an NGO working in the field of tobacco control, has requested the Centre to support Union Health Ministry's decision to end manufacture, distribution, import and sale of e-cigarettes and ensure that such products are banned.

The NGO said that the Health Ministry's decision against e-cigarettes and similar such products is "correct and laudable".

"...All other Ministries must support this move Ministry of Health and ensure that such products are banned and are not included as legal products under the COTPA (Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products Act) or the Drugs and Cosmetics Act," Mandakini Sinh (Managing Trustee) of National Health Forum said in a letter dated August 27 to the Health Minister Harsh Vardhan.

In the letter, she said that the Ministry of Health along with WHO (World Health Organisation) and domestic NGOs for the past many decades have worked "zealously" to ensure that cigarettes and other tobacco products are manufactured in reasonable and limited quantities and to that effect it is a licensed product with licensed capacities.

"Any easing of these norms will lead to a deluge of these tobacco products which are pernicious to health."

After a lot of thought, the Health Ministry in consultation with various NGOs had issued an advisory for states to ban e-cigarettes, e-vaps and e-hookah, Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems (ENDS) and similar such products, said Sinh, adding thereafter, about a dozen States have banned these products including Maharashtra, Punjab, Bihar, Karnataka, Gujarat and Rajasthan.

"There is a concerned attempt by importers of E-cigarettes to ensure that the Ministry of Health's good work done providing a platform for prohibition of imports of these products is frustrated. To this end, it has been brought to our attention that various representations and legal challenges have been mounted by them."

Noting that about 30 countries in the world, including various states of the US, have banned the production, import and sale of e-cigarettes, she said regulatory pressure on these products in their home markets is now compelling them to target developing economies like India.

In fact, Sinh said, international cigarette companies are involved in the manufacture of these products.

Mentioning that claims made by the manufacturers of E-cigarettes that they are "reduced harm alternatives" are not proven by any independent scientific studies, she said what the international conventional tobacco products manufacturers are doing is to use e-cigarettes as a gateway product in luring the youth.

"The idea is to introduce the young teenage user to E-cigarettes and then graduate them to the more conventional tobacco products. Infact, from studies conducted by the WHO and several independent scientific bodies it is clear that e-cigarettes can have adverse health effects like pulmonary and cardio- vascular diseases," Sinh said.

By falsely spreading the idea that E-cigarettes are safe or reduced harm alternatives, she said a situation is being created in the minds of gullible youth of our Country to swing them from being non-smokers to smokers.

"It is in this context that I have observed a barrage of representations being made to the government, courts and in both, the print and electronic media as well as in social media," she added.