Live
- Ten Arrested in Dacoity Case
- Egypt's new govt holds first meeting with focus on resolving power outage
- Chinese geologists unearth novel minerals at world's largest rare-earth mine
- NIA submits chargesheet in 2022 Bengal blast case
- Singapore authority seizes more than $6 million worth of vapes
- Slovak, Polish Presidents hail ties, discuss NATO Summit
- Pocso case: Bengaluru court summons former CM Yediyurappa on July 15
- Bangladesh PM Sheikh Hasina to visit China next week
- Another case filed in Bihar against Rahul Gandhi for remarks on Hindus
- JP Nadda to visit Jammu and Kashmir on July 6
Just In
Extension of ED chief's tenure illegal, amicus curiae tells Supreme Court
![](/images/authorplaceholder.jpg)
![Extension of ED chiefs tenure illegal, amicus curiae tells Supreme Court Extension of ED chiefs tenure illegal, amicus curiae tells Supreme Court](https://assets.thehansindia.com/h-upload/2023/02/27/1338789-ed.webp)
Extension of ED chief's tenure illegal, amicus curiae tells Supreme Court
Senior advocate KV Viswanathan, the amicus curiae in the petitions challenging the extension of the tenure of Director of Enforcement Directorate (ED) Sanjay Kumar Mishra, told the Supreme Court on Monday that the extension was illegal
New Delhi: Senior advocate KV Viswanathan, the amicus curiae in the petitions challenging the extension of the tenure of Director of Enforcement Directorate (ED) Sanjay Kumar Mishra, told the Supreme Court on Monday that the extension was illegal. Viswanathan cited the apex court's decisions in Vineet Narain & others v. Union of India and Common Cause v. Union of India to support his contention. He submitted before a bench of Justices BR Gavai and Aravind Kumar that the issue was not about the incumbent Director at all, rather it was about the principle.
The amicus further contended that that extension is illegal not just because of the direction in Common Cause judgment that Mishra should not be given further extension beyond November 2021, but due to specific observation made in the judgment that extension should be granted only in exceptional circumstances.
The top court was hearing a batch of petitions challenging the extension of tenure of ED Director and the 2021 amendment to the Central Vigilance Commission Act 2003, which enables Centre to extend the tenure of the ED Director.
Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, representing one of the petitioners, assailed the extension on the ground that 'piecemeal' extensions impinged on the independence of an official and when tenures are fixed, it gives public officials strength and infuses them with independent objectives.
Singhvi said: "Here, a statute is effectively saying that the tenure will be extended for a period not exceeding one year, but as many as five times. The message is clear that such an extension would not be granted if the official fails to do the executive's biddinga..."
Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan suggested that on the day when the matter is taken up for the hearing, the amicus curiae could open the submissions. Solicitor-General Tushar Mehta, however, said the amicus can open submissions only after the preliminary objection made by the ED against the locus standi of the petitioners is decided.
After hearing submissions, the top court scheduled the matter for further hearing on March 21.
In a written response, the Central government has told the Supreme Court that the PIL challenging the extension of tenure of ED chief Mishra has been filed with the intention of protecting Congress leaders who are facing money laundering charges.
In a counter-affidavit, the Centre said the PIL is clearly motivated and is admittedly intended to scuttle the legitimate statutory investigation being carried out by the ED against certain politically exposed persons. "The real motive of the petition is to question the investigation being carried out against the president and certain office bearers of Indian National Congress (INC)...", it claimed.
![](/images/logo.png)
© 2024 Hyderabad Media House Limited/The Hans India. All rights reserved. Powered by hocalwire.com